If you’re looking for the best Islamorada restaurants for the perfect vacation getaway, you’ve come to the right place! (Or the right article!)
Islamorada is a place of natural beauty that attracts people from all over the world. But if you’re coming to Islamorada and want to find places to eat, you might not know where to start. That’s why we’ve compiled this list of places for you!
The Islamorada Fish Company
- Location: 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: islandfishco.com
“Purple Isle” is the meaning behind the name, Islamorada. Early Florida Keys residents gave the place its name around 1907. The Islamorada Fish Company restaurant originally opened its doors in 1948.
They are the most sought-after location, which looks out over the breathtaking Florida Gulf Coast bayside with famous sunsets and gentle bay breezes. To host the ideal event, their knowledgeable staff and banquet coordinators will collaborate with you.
The Zane Grey Long Key Lounge is also housed here; it’s on the second floor of World Wide Sportsman in Islamorada. Fishing enthusiasts could enjoy the Total Package in Angling, Dining, and Entertainment thanks to the 1997 opening of Zane Grey Lounge and World Wide Sportsman.
The lounge itself is a homage to the Long Key Fishing Club, which the illustrious Zane Grey established in 1917 in the Florida Keys, close to Layton, Florida. Legendary sportsmen and entertainers like Curt Gowdy, Clarence Clemons, Stu Apte, Ted Williams, and many others have enjoyed the Zane Grey Lounge’s Rod and Gun atmosphere.
Favorite menu item: Stuffed Shrimp – Key West Pink Gold Shrimp wrapped in bacon, topped with Monterey Jack, cheddar cheese & bbq sauce. Served with chef’s rice and veggies. The perfect combos!
Keys Fisheries - Restaurant, Market, & Marina
Freshest Seafood in Florida Keys: Keys Fisheries Market & Marina by Tidy Island
- Location: 3502 Gulfview Ave, Marathon, FL 33050
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: keysfisheries.com
Keys Fisheries is conveniently located in the center of the Florida Keys, north of Marathon’s 7 Mile Bridge. Visitors can enjoy the stunning, tropical paradise that is the magnificent Florida Keys. The seafood restaurant is situated on the shore of Florida Bay, providing loyal patrons with stunning vistas and spectacular sunsets.
Visitors can travel to the Florida Keys for lunch or dinner by boat or can rent dockage for both short- and long-term visits. The marina offers convenient access to and from the marina and dockage for yachts up to 60 feet in length.
Favorite menu item: World Famous Lobster Reuben – toasted rye, kraut, Swiss Cheese, Thousand Island dressing
Discover hidden-gem beaches, explore the Florida Keys food scene, find the perfect accommodation, experience the Keys’ stunning waters, and much more.
The Island Grill
- Location: 85501 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: keysislandgrill.com
In Islamorada, at milepost 85 on the southern end of the Snake Creek Bridge on the river, is The Island Grill. On the inside as well as the outside, The Island Grill isn’t very attractive. But they start serving delicious cuisine at 7:00 a.m. alongside breakfast.
Although the interior and exterior of this Florida beach bar are primitive, isn’t that what we would expect from a beach bar in the Florida Keys? This place is a well-liked hangout location for celebrations and weddings. You can see live entertainment in the evenings.
Favorite menu item: The Original Tuna Nachos – fresh raw sushi grade tuna, seaweed salad, crispy wontons, topped with wasabi mayo, teriyaki glaze, sesame seeds, sriracha, scallions
Morada Bay Beach Café
- Location: 81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: moradabaykeys.com/dining/beach-cafe
The Morada Bay Beach Diner is a sand-filled, outdoor Mediterranean cafe. To reach your table, which is situated with a view of the azure waves and palm trees, you must first stroll through the sand and then follow a path decorated with tropical flowers. This is the ideal location to begin your holiday and set the mood for relaxation.
Enjoy the numerous wine options, cold drinks, and cocktails if you plan to stay a while. If it’s only a quick pit stop on your way there, you can indulge in the island-inspired meal made with fresh local seafood and produce.
Favorite menu item: Tacos – they have Mahi Mahi Street Tacos and Thai Key West Tacos to choose from, which both taste good!
Atlantic's Edge
- Location: 81801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$$$
- Website: cheeca.com/dine-drink/atlantics-edge
Savor a meal while taking in the scenery at Atlantic’s Edge, a premier seafood restaurant in Islamorada that specializes in Key West cuisine. This Islamorada restaurant features panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and both indoor and outdoor dining options.
With a focus on using fresh, regional foods from the Florida Keys, Atlantic’s Edge is a culinary journey through the Caribbean and Atlantic Ocean islands. This chef-driven eatery offers a contemporary twist on island-inspired cooking that honors the tastes, customs, and culinary traditions of islands ranging from Islamorada to Cuba, the Bahamas to Turks & Caicos.
Favorite menu item: Yellowtail Snapper – with Haitian Pikliz and Pineapple Chutney
Mia Cucina
- Location: 81801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: cheeca.com/dine-drink/mia-cucina
Mia Cucina is a cozy, Neapolitan pizzeria that brings Naples, Italy right into the center of Islamorada. It serves freshly produced artisanal pizzas, pasta, and salads in a fun, family-friendly atmosphere.
In addition to other reinvented and traditional Italian favorites, the menu features fresh and savory highlights that are prepared in front of you, such as Margarita Pizza, Key West Pink Shrimp Tuscan Cavatelli, Red and Green Tomato Burrata Caprese, Italian soft drinks, beers, and wine.
Favorite menu item: Pizzas – they have various pizza flavors to choose from!
The Lazy Lobster
- Location: 102770 Overseas Hwy Mile Marker 102, Bayside, Key Largo, FL 33037-2730
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: lazylobsterinthekeys.com
Visit The Lazy Lobster at Mile Marker 102 in Bayside to join hosts Chef Lupe Ledesma and David Ornelas. Enjoy excellent fresh fish and cuisine prepared in the Keys.
Fresh seafood, seafood pastas, vegetarian pastas, sandwiches, steaks, and chicken are all available at Lazy Lobster for affordable prices. Chef Lupe will prepare your catch as well!
Daily lobster specials, a children’s menu, amazing handcrafted desserts, and a selection of beers and wines are available. Dine inside or outside on the expansive tiki-adorned patio with a tropical setting. Every night, enjoy soothing live music!
Favorite menu item: Lobster – patrons love all things lobster!
Chef Michael's
Hogfish Juliette from Chef Michael’s by WSVN-TV
- Location: 81671 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$$$
- Website: foodtotalkabout.com
Elegant dining in a relaxed island environment is a specialty of Chef Michael’s. The restaurant is renowned for having Islamorada’s best selection of freshly caught fish and offers upmarket fish dishes as well as contemporary American cuisine.
The restaurant’s eponymous chef-owner, Michael Ledwith, started his career in some of New York’s top dining establishments. He eventually traveled to the Caribbean, where he acquired the skill of seafood preparation. His restaurant is regarded as one of the best in the Upper Keys. He made a name for himself in Central Florida before being drawn to the island lifestyle in The Keys.
Favorite menu item: Hogfish – you can choose to prepare it in any way you prefer!
Green Turtle Inn
- Location: 81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: greenturtleinn.com
The Green Turtle Inn can be your go-to lunch spot if you’re just passing through Islamorada and won’t be there long. The Green Turtle Inn, a landmark in Islamorada, has been a favorite among locals since 1947. It may be familiar to you because it was featured on the Food Network show Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives.
Green Turtle Inn offers genuine Keys cuisine and charming old-Florida atmosphere. The relaxed cafe serves meals like Florida Keys delicacies and southern favorites for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Favorite menu item: Turtle Chowder – a restaurant specialty with pepper sherry
Mangrove Mama's
- Location: 82200 Overseas Hwy MM 82, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Price: $$ – $$$
- Website: facebook.com/mangrovemamas20
Mangrove Mama’s is the place to go if you want to unwind and enjoy the best meals in Sugarloaf Key.
Mangrove Mama’s has been a renowned restaurant for over 40 years, earning a reputation for providing the finest local seafood, unique beverages, and prize-winning desserts. You can enjoy your meals and drinks inside or on an outdoor patio surrounded by palm trees, with live music and a tropical Florida ambiance.
Favorite menu item: Seafood Quesadilla – chipotle mayo, shredded cabbage, pickled onions
Don't Miss These Islamorada Restaurants
No matter what you’re in the mood for, Islamorada has a place where you can eat! So don’t miss out on these great places to eat while you’re in the area. But here’s a bonus: Check out this blog to learn more about Square Grouper Islamorada – another famous dining spot that will elevate your experience!
This list of places to eat is by no means exhaustive – there are many, many more places to eat in Islamorada. But we hope this gives you a good starting point for finding something to eat while you enjoy your time at the beaches.
Related Articles
Square Grouper Islamorada offers inventive dining focused on reliability and quality at MM 80.4, bayside along Islamorada Marina. They are all about fresh, regional seafood, some of the best craft cocktails, a great wine list, and first-rate service.
Islamorada fishing charters help retain the island’s “Sportfishing Capital of the World” title, as it caters to anglers of all skill levels. The town features a variety of fish species due to its access to gin-clear flats, pristine backcountry, and open ocean.
If you’re seeking a place with a tropical climate and a serene ambiance, you shouldn’t miss out on the most fun things to do in Islamorada! This place should be at the top of your trip wish list.
Places to Eat in Islamorada FAQs
If you’re coming to Islamorada and want to find places to eat, you might not know where to start. Here are the most popular restaurants worth visiting.
- The Grille at Islamorada Fish Company
- The Keys Fisheries Market & Restaurant
- The Island Grill
- Morada Bay Beach Café
- Cheeca Lodge & Spa
- Woody’s Waterfront Café
- The Lazy Lobster
- Cabana Breezes
- Tarpon Creek Grill
- Mangrove Mama’s
The most well-known restaurants in Islamorada that offer takeout include:
- Bayside Gourmet
- Twisted shrimp
- Wahoo’s Bar and Grill
There is a wide variety of food available in Key West that you simply don’t see on a daily basis elsewhere. Here is a list of the best local dishes in Key West.
- Key lime pie
- Coconut water
- Conch chowder
- Spiny lobster
- Pink shrimp
- Conch fritters
- Fish sandwich
